...First Do No Harm (1997)

...First Do No Harm (1997)

Saving Robbie

Meryl Streep in ...First Do No Harm (1997)

When Lori Reimuller (Meryl Streep) receives a call from the school to say her youngest, Robbie (Seth Adkins), had a fall she thinks it is just one of those things and takes him home. But when he has a seizure she rushes him to hospital where she and her husband Dave (Fred Ward) are told that two seizures means he has epilepsy. Placed on medication to try and control his seizures it causes Robbie to become hyper active which leads to another drug which saps the life out of him. all the time the seizures not only continue but get progressively worse. Despite discovering that their medical insurance doesn't cover Robbie's treatment they put their faith in the medical establishment as Robbie ends up being admitted to hospital when a drug turns him violent and another drug puts him into a permanent state of seizure. Realising that the medical team don't have a cure Lori visits a friend who has epilepsy for advice whilst Dave deals with not only the spiralling costs but the impact Robbie's condition has on the rest of the family. With no improvement Lori takes it upon herself to research treatments for epilepsy and discovers the ketogenic diet could help but finds herself being blocked by doctors who dismiss the treatment in favour of more drug treatment and possibly surgery.

Anyone who regularly visits The Movie Scene will know I am a fan of TV movies and as such I have to say it is rare to come across one which not only has a star of the calibre of Meryl Streep but also has a mainstream director as Jim Abrahams. These two certainly make a difference and lift "...First Do No Harm" to the point that it doesn't feel like a TV movie but it is also Abrahams' personal interest as his own son's epilepsy was controlled by the ketogenic diet which helps to make it above average. His interest makes the movie not only more realistic but also more rational as "...First Do No Harm" is the sort of movie which could easily have gone over board and not only become a spiteful attacking movie of the medical establishment but also a schmatlzy one.

Fred Ward in ...First Do No Harm (1997)

Now there are two sides to "...First Do No Harm" and the first side is a look at epilepsy which is hard going for those who have dealt with this illness and eye opening for those who are naive to it. We go from what seems an innocent fall to frequent and dangerous seizures as well as the constant testing of medication which may or may not work. We see how treating epilepsy almost comes down to luck as to what drugs will work whilst also seeing the side effects some dugs have. And of course we get to see the impact of Robbie's epilepsy on the family, from the escalating cost of treatment to how it emotionally affects other members of the family. It is a thorough look at the illness with out being just facts and will open people's eyes who have never come had dealings with epilepsy.

But then there is the second side to "...First Do No Harm" and that is to be frank the condemnation of the medical establishment who at the time, and maybe still are, are blinkered to alternative treatments. What that means is that we see how the doctors won't listen to Lori when she brings up the ketogenic diet as they have their drugs and surgery to try. Now this is where "...First Do No Harm" could have become seriously far fetched and overly dramatic but thanks to Jim Abrahams he keeps it under control so whilst there is plenty of drama including a scene where out of desperation Lori tries to sneak her son out of the hospital it never becomes about dramatic sensationalism but always the battle for what is best for Robbie.

All of this makes "...First Do No Harm" a powerful movie with a great storyline but it is also a made for TV movie with above average performances. I am not just on about Meryl Streep who is, as you would expect, good but the rest of the cast which includes Fred Ward, Tom Butler and Margo Martindale all step up their game to deliver believable characters. But at the same time a young Seth Adkins also needs to be mentioned because his delivery of the seizures is uncomfortably real.

What this all boils down to is that "...First Do No Harm" is an above average made for TV movie which is both eye opening and hard hitting. For those who are dealing with a friend or relative with epilepsy it will help explain things and at the same time will be educational for those who have never been confronted by the illness.

Movie Recommendations


David's Mother (1994)

"David's Mother" is the story of Sally Goodson (Kirstie Alley - Deadly Purs ...


Jewel (2001)

Having already had 4 children Jewel (Farrah Fawcett - The Cannonball Run) a ...


Society's Child (2002)

Evidently "Society's Child" is based on the true story of Katie Lynn Baker, ...

My Body, My Child

My Body, My Child (1982)

The death of her mum left Leenie Cabrezi (Vanessa Redgrave - Yanks) feeling ...

What Makes a Family

What Makes a Family (2001)

Janine Nielssen (Brooke Shields - The Bachelor) and Sandy Cataldi (Cherry J ...


Gracie's Choice: A Story of Love (2004)

All her life 16 year old Gracie (Kristen Bell) has cared for her 3 brothers ...

Saving Milly

Saving Milly (2005)

Speaking to the Senate in Washington Mort Kondracke (Bruce Greenwood - I Ro ...

The Memory Keeper

The Memory Keeper's Daughter (2008)

Going into labour early Dr. David Henry (Dermot Mulroney - Zodiac) rushes h ...

More Than Meets the Eye: The Joan Brock Story

More Than Meets the Eye: The Joan Brock Story (2003)

Both Joan (Carey Lowell) and her husband Joe (Rod Wilson) work at the Iowa ...

Freshman Father

Freshman Father (2010)

With her boyfriend John (Drew Seeley) heading off to Harvard Kathy (Britt I ...

Two Against Time

Two Against Time (2002)

As a divorced single mum Julie Portman (Marlo Thomas) not only holds down a ...

The Russell Girl

The Russell Girl (2008)

23 year old Sarah Russell (Amber Tamblyn) is working in Macy's whilst putti ...

Candles on Bay Street

Candles on Bay Street (2006)

Sam (Eion Bailey) and Lydia Timmons (Annabeth Gish) have a nice life togeth ...

A Place Called Home

A Place Called Home (2004)

With her eye sight failing Tula (Ann-Margret - Any Given Sunday) has resign ...

Our House

Our House (2006)

Ruth Galloway is finding life hard (Doris Roberts - A Time to Remember), sh ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS