A Christmas Proposal (2008)

A Christmas Proposal (2008)

Same Old Christmas Developments

Nicole Eggert in A Christmas Proposal (2008)

Developer Alexander Malone (Tom Arnold - Pride) is trying to cut a deal to redevelop the small town of Fillmore but he needs to get the deal in place by the holiday season. So he sends his daughter Reagan (Sarah Thompson) and future son-in-law Rick (David O'Donnell) to go and get the deal sorted using Rick's connections as he grew up in Fillmore. But whilst some of the town are in favour of the development there are those opposed including former girlfriend and local lawyer Lisa (Nicole Eggert - Snowman's Pass). But when Rick's car breaks down and he has to stay in Fillmore longer than he had planned he not only starts to fall back in love with the old town but discovers there are still feelings between him and Lisa.

Within 5 minutes of "A Christmas Proposal" starting I could have switched it off, written this review and tried to find a better Christmas movie to watch because this does nothing more than reworks a familiar old story. As such if you have never watched one of those TV movies before where a city slicker heads back to their childhood small town and runs in to a former girlfriend "A Christmas Proposal" might just come across as entertain. But for those who have, and there is a good chance you will have as it is one of the most frequently used themes, this Christmas movie offers up nothing new or better than those other movies.

David O'Donnell in A Christmas Proposal (2008)

So what does that mean well let me give you how "A Christmas Proposal" comes across. David O'Donnell has been cast as Rick because he is handsome and has a touch of Patrick Dempsey about him. Sarah Thompson is in there as she does spoilt rich girl who can't function without her cell phone quite nicely. Tom Arnold quite literally phones in his performance as he is barely in the movie and when he is he appears on the phone. And then there is Nicole Eggert who does hometown nice quite nicely but looks like she wants the movie to be over right from the first time we meet her.

There is of course the storyline which is of course mixed with some small town humour but not only is the story familiar but so are the jokes. Gags about a small town garage unable to get the parts or no cell phone reception might make the new to this sort of movie smile but offers nothing for veterans of the TV movie genre. And as for Christmas spirit it has none, seriously it has none other than some Christmas decorations scattered around the sets.

What this all boils down to is that "A Christmas Proposal" might just about amuse young teenage girls but for anyone else it is just a lame reworking of a familiar theme which other than some Christmas decorations doesn't have a lot of Christmas magic going on.

Tags: Christmas Movies

Movie Recommendations

A Christmas Visitor

A Christmas Visitor (2002)

For the past 11 years the Boyajian's have not bothered to celebrate Christm ...

The Christmas Blessing

The Christmas Blessing (2005)

After loosing a teenager on the operating table Dr. Nathan Andrews (Neil Pa ...

Angels and Ornaments

Angels and Ornaments (2014)

Christmas is coming and whilst Corrine (Jessalyn Gilsig) still hasn't got o ...

Prancer Returns

Prancer Returns (2001)

After her marriage broke down Denise Holton (Stacy Edwards - The Bachelor) ...

Off Season

Off Season (2001)

It's been two months since little Jackson Mayhew (Rory Culkin - You Can Cou ...

The Christmas Card

The Christmas Card (2006)

Whilst serving in Afghanistan, US Army sergeant Cody Cullen (John Newton - ...

The Christmas Ornament

The Christmas Ornament (2013)

For Kathy (Kellie Martin) this is the first Christmas since her beloved hus ...

Christmas in Canaan

Christmas in Canaan (2009)

When Daniel Burton hears (Billy Ray Cyrus) that his son DJ got into a fight ...

The Christmas Choir

The Christmas Choir (2008)

It's nineteen days till Christmas and accountant Peter Brockman (Jason Gedr ...

Gift of the Magi

Gift of the Magi (2010)

Newly weds Jim (Mark Webber) and Della Alexander (Marla Sokoloff - Flower G ...

Angel in the Family

Angel in the Family (2004)

Sometime after his wife passed away Buddy Brice (Ronny Cox) is living with ...

A Christmas Tree Miracle

A Christmas Tree Miracle (2013)

The George family are doing well with Christmas coming: David George (Kevin ...

November Christmas

November Christmas (2010)

Tom Marks (John Corbett) and his wife Beth (Sarah Paulson) are concerned th ...

The Christmas Shoes

The Christmas Shoes (2002)

Ever since he was a child Robert Layton (Rob Lowe - Austin Powers: The Spy ...

A Perfect Day

A Perfect Day (2006)

Having been made redundant from his marketing Job, family man Rob Harlan (R ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS