Movie Details
Recommendation

A Christmas Promise (2015)

 
 

The Cliches Flow this Christmas

Charisma Carpenter and Patrick Muldoon in A Christmas Promise (2015)

Christmas is coming and city accountant Michael Thompson (Patrick Muldoon) is frustrated by everyone taking holidays whilst also struggling to be a single dad to his rebellious teenage daughter Chloe (Mandalynn Carlson). So his assistant says he should kill two birds with one stone as her uncle Cliff Harrison (Rick Herod) has a horse ranch and could do with some financial advice as things are not going well whilst it would give Michael chance to bond with his daughter. But one of Cliff's daughters Samantha (Charisma Carpenter) initially doesn't want any outside help and is certainly not going to go out of her way to make Michael feel welcomed. But with the bank going to foreclose on the 26th December unless they pay off their debts there needs to be a Christmas miracle or two.

For some Christmas is the season for forgiveness, for others it is the season of gift giving whilst for me it is the season of watching Christmas movies. But as such whilst I come across a few gems each Christmas season far too many of these Christmas movies end up being forgettably average thanks to the simple fact that either they are not really Christmas movies or do little to disguise familiar cliches or do so in a far too cheesy manner. Sadly there is something about "A Christmas Promise", which is also known as "A Horse Tale", which doesn't quite work, which simply stops it from being an okay reworking of those familiar cliches.

Dominique Swain in A Christmas Promise (2015)

Now you can break "A Christmas Promise" down to some very familiar cliches; we have a family run ranch in financial trouble on the verge of being repossessed by the bank, a city business man who doesn't do country who is also a struggling, over protective single father dealing with a rebellious teen daughter, some horse drama and of course there is the obligatory slice of romance. For those who love their TV movies will know exactly how this will play out and for those who don't just think about what the best outcome would be for all those involved and you will know how it will play out. The trouble for me is that it doesn't really attempt to disguise these familiar elements or do anything with them which breaks the mold.

But there is no denying that "A Christmas Promise" is a good looking movie with plenty of modern day horse ranch charm, good looking people, good looking scenery and a good heart. And in a way it is the goodness of it all, that everyone in this movie is good in their own way that makes it watchable. Well that and the entire cast from Charisma Carpenter and Patrick Muldoon down to Dominique Swain and Mandalynn Carlson are likeable.

What this all boils down to is that "A Christmas Promise" is nothing new, in fact everything about it is incredibly familiar which means it holds few surprises when it comes to how things play out. But at the same time it is a nice looking movie with a likeable cast which helps to make it watchable.

close

Movie Recommendations

Christmas in Conway

Christmas in Conway (2013)

When the hospice agrees to let Suzy Mayor (Mary-Louise Parker) return home ...

Oh Christmas Tree

Oh Christmas Tree (2013)

The one thing Elise MacReynolds (Sarah Lancaster) remembers about Christmas ...

The Christmas Shepherd

The Christmas Shepherd (2014)

When her late husband returned home from service overseas he brought back B ...

A Cookie Cutter Christmas

A Cookie Cutter Christmas (2014)

Once upon a time, a long long time ago Christie Reynolds (Erin Krakow) and ...

The Christmas Ornament

The Christmas Ornament (2013)

For Kathy (Kellie Martin) this is the first Christmas since her beloved hus ...

Trading Christmas

Trading Christmas (2011)

Feeling that she wants to do something different for Christmas Boston Unive ...

Angels and Ornaments

Angels and Ornaments (2014)

Christmas is coming and whilst Corrine (Jessalyn Gilsig) still hasn't got o ...

A Cookie Cutter Christmas

A Cookie Cutter Christmas (2014)

Once upon a time, a long long time ago Christie Reynolds (Erin Krakow) and ...

Christmas Under Wraps

Christmas Under Wraps (2014)

Third year surgical resident Lauren Brunell (Candace Cameron Bure) has her ...

Mr. Miracle

Mr. Miracle (2014)

Untested angel Harry Mills (Rob Morrow) finds himself sent to Earth for the ...

Chilly Christmas

Chilly Christmas (2012)

Bobby's (Bryson Sams) best friend is Chilly Christmas, the dog which his da ...

Holiday Road Trip

Holiday Road Trip (2013)

With Christmas coming Maya (Ashley Scott - We've Got Christmas Mail) though ...

12 Dogs of Christmas: Great Puppy Rescue

12 Dogs of Christmas: Great Puppy Rescue (2012)

December, 1937, 6 years after making the town which hated dogs like them, E ...

A Bulldog for Christmas

A Bulldog for Christmas (2013)

It's the 22nd December and college student Sally Kroger (Marylee Osborne) d ...

Scoot & Kassie

Scoot & Kassie's Christmas Adventure (2013)

Having just moved to Heber Valley with his daughters Kassie (Ariana Bagley) ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS