Not Good Enough

Viggo Mortensen in Good (2008)

Literary professor, John Haider (Viggo Mortensen), lives in a changing world as the Nazi Regime is building whilst he looks after his family, including his ill mother (Gemma Jones) and finds himself having feeling for Anne (Jodie Whitaker), a student. But a book which Haider writes on euthanasia brings him to the attention of the Nazi hierarchy, including Hitler himself. And in turn Haider finds himself pressed into working with the Gestapo and writing about legalizing euthanasia.

Euthanasia, the Nazi Regime, civilian naivety, friendship with a Jew and an affair. Those are 5 big elements in the movie "Good", or should I say they should be 5 big elements in the movie "Good". Unfortunately the power of exploring those elements never manifests itself on the screen leaving "Good" a movie which flits between all the different elements but never really manifests the depths of the subjects. Basically one minute it is touching on the subject of euthanasia with John's mother wanting to die but then it flies off to look at the strained marriage, then his friendship with Maurice, a Jewish psychiatrist and so it goes on. It really puts the pieces in place but never manages to do anything with them.

But what "Good" achieves is to deliver this look, this mix of period drama with a touch of autumnal hue to make a beautifully looking movie. And in fairness whilst some of the dialogue is to text book the acting is good through out with both Viggo Mortensen and Jason Isaacs delivering characters who are easy to connect with.

What this all boils down to is that "Good" ends up a missed opportunity a movie with a lot of scope but is unable to do credit to all of the elements.

Movie Recommendations

The Man Who Captured Eichmann

The Man Who Captured Eichmann (1996)

When a young woman takes her blind father to meet her boyfriend and his fat ...


Eichmann (2007)

Now that as you would guess means that I am no expert on Eichmann, his acti ...

The Odessa File

The Odessa File (1974)

Freelance journalist Peter Miller (Jon Voight - Four Christmases) finds him ...

The Plot to Kill Hitler

The Plot to Kill Hitler (1990)

As a soldier being groomed for greatness Count Claus von Stauffenberg (Brad ...


Valkyrie (2008)

As a soldier in Tunisia Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg (Tom Cruise) was alr ...

Operation Valkyrie

Operation Valkyrie (2004)

"Operation Valkyrie" actual starts in 1933 as we witness Claus Schenk Graf ...

Hitler: The Rise of Evil

Hitler: The Rise of Evil (2003)

But as I pointed out my historical knowledge is far from in depth and my co ...

The Bunker

The Bunker (1981)

With the allies relentless pressure becoming too much Hitler (Anthony Hopki ...

The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas

The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas (2008)

As an 8 year old growing up in Berlin Bruno (Asa Butterfield) doesn't under ...


Uprising (2001)

One minute the centre of Warsaw was a thriving community, a bustling market ...

Hidden in Silence

Hidden in Silence (1996)

With the Polish town of Przemysl split in two with the Germans on one side ...

Escape from Sobibor

Escape from Sobibor (1987)

Now "Escape from Sobibor" is a movie of two halves and the first half typic ...


Schindler's List (1993)

With Polish Jews being moved to the Krakow Ghetto, German businessman Oskar ...

The Devil

The Devil's Arithmetic (1999)

As a teenage Jew living in the modern world and hanging out with non Jewish ...

The Pianist

The Pianist (2002)

As the bombing of Warsaw starts to destroy buildings and cause panic, music ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS