A Cowboy Christmas Carol

Jack Palance in Ebenezer (1998)

It's Christmas eve and land baron Ebenezer Scrooge (Jack Palance) is up to no good as always, cheating young Samuel Benson (Ricky Schroder) out of his money, land and horse when he enters into a card game with the old miser hoping he could win some money so he could marry Erica (Amy Locane) the niece of Ebenezer's departed friend Jacob. After ending up losing it all and being given till Christmas morning to vacate his home and land Samuel heads home whilst Ebenezer heads to his office not before he fires his assistant Bob (Albert Schultz) who discovers Ebenezer's crooked card table. But later that night Ebenezer gets a visit from three ghosts who giving him an alternate view of his life; past, present and yet to come when in the morning he will end up in a stand off with Samuel.

For about the first 15 minutes "Ebenezer" had me, here was an entertaining version of Dickens' "A Christmas Carol", taking it out to the West and having him a man who became a bitter man through a series of events. The whole opening which sees him as a crooked gambler who cheats a young man out of everything he owns is a nice twist on the original and having Scrooge's nephew being a mail man is also a nice twist. But of course after some unique ideas we then hit the familiar aspect with the three ghosts and truth be told it starts to lose you.

And in truth I am trying to work out what the problem with "Ebenezer" is because in many ways it is good. The look at how Ebenezer became a bitter, greedy man is an entertaining one and switching Bah Humbug for Hogwash is a nice switch up. There are many more changes and switches which help to make this familiar but not just a case of dropping Dickens' story into a western scenario, the whole duel in the street is a nice idea. I think the trouble is that rather than having some grit and drama it is a bit too light and floaty, even being a bit spoof like such as when out of nowhere Scrooge calls someone Pilgrim. Basically at times "Ebenezer" feels too weak and unsure of what sort of movie it wants to be.

What this all boils down to is that "Ebenezer" is a novel idea but it is one where the novelty wears off and after that it struggles to really do anything to make it stand out from the familiarity of the well known storyline. Even the great Jack Palance is unable to make this work and at times seems to struggle with some of the corny dialogue he has to deliver.

Tags: TV Christmas Movies, Christmas Movies, A Christmas Carol

Movie Recommendations

A Christmas Carol

A Christmas Carol (2000)

Eddie Scrooge (Ross Kemp) is a ruthless money lender/ debt collector who do ...

An American Christmas Carol

An American Christmas Carol (1979)

Times are hard in America as the Great Depression leave families desperate ...

Scrooged

Scrooged (1988)

Frank Cross (Bill Murray - Ghostbusters) is a TV executive who is known for ...

A Diva

A Diva's Christmas Carol (2000)

Ebony Scrooge (Vanessa Williams) is a huge pop star but behind the scenes s ...

It

It's Christmas, Carol! (2012)

It's Christmas Eve and as the head of a publishing empire Carol (Emmanuelle ...

Karroll

Karroll's Christmas (2004)

Allen Karroll (Tom Everett Scott) doesn't do Christmas ever since an embarr ...

The Muppet Christmas Carol

The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)

To be frank most people will have seen at least one version or another of C ...

Miracle at Christmas - Ebbie

Miracle at Christmas - Ebbie's Story (1995)

It is Christmas Eve and Elizabeth 'Ebbie' Scrooge (Susan Lucci) only cares ...

Ms. Scrooge

Ms. Scrooge (1997)

So as I said "Ms. Scrooge" follows the traditional narrative of "A Christma ...

A Carol Christmas

A Carol Christmas (2003)

Under the guidance of her late Aunt Marla (Dinah Manoff), Carol (Tori Spell ...

A Christmas Carol: The Musical

A Christmas Carol: The Musical (2004)

Christmas is coming and Ebenezer Scrooge (Kelsey Grammer) is in his usual b ...

Ghosts of Girlfriends Past

Ghosts of Girlfriends Past (2009)

Connor Mead (Matthew McConaughey) is a man on top, on top of one hot date a ...

A Valentine Carol

A Valentine Carol (2007)

Ally Sims (Emma Caulfield) is a busy woman as she hosts her own Seattle rad ...

A Christmas Carol

A Christmas Carol (2009)

I won't bother with a synopsis as to be honest Dickens' "A Christmas Carol" ...

By God

By God's Grace (2014)

His parent's worked hard at building up their air charter service, but alon ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS