Deadly Sibling Rivalry (2011)

Deadly Sibling Rivalry (2011)

Carpenter's Troublesome Twins

Charisma Carpenter in Deadly Sibling Rivalry (2011)

Ever since they were young twins Janna and Callie (Charisma Carpenter) have never got on and when their father died whilst climbing with Janna, Callie has blamed her sister for his death. Now many years later they end up in a car accident together and with the police after Callie over the theft of prescription drugs she switches places, pretending to be Janna as the real Janna lies in hospital in a coma. With the police believing that Callie is the one in a coma Callie is sure she can pull it off pretending to be her goody two shoes sister. Except Janna's daughter Fiona (Christa B. Allen) begins to suspect things are not right and when she is sure that it is really her mum in the hospital bed it causes the real Callie to take some desperate measures to try and conceal the truth.

Whilst I have watched a variety of movies surrounding identical twins I can't recollect one which has a similar story to "Deadly Sibling Rivalry" which sees a bad twin wanted by the police switching places with her good twin following a car accident. Having said that "Deadly Sibling Rivalry" doesn't really create any surprises either as the bad twin goes to some desperate lengths to conceal the truth including murder. What that means is that "Deadly Sibling Rivalry" is an entertaining if far fetched movie which unsurprisingly seeing that we are talking a made for TV movie suffers from some usual issues none more so than some gaping plot holes.

Christa B. Allen in Deadly Sibling Rivalry (2011)

In truth I quite enjoyed watching "Deadly Sibling Rivalry" and whilst elements of the story were familiar it still kept me entertained. It isn't so much that it features a strong storyline, in fact there are those numerous gaping plot holes which should have brought things to a close much sooner but there is something entertaining about the desperate choices which Callie makes to hide the truth. Having said that, after various twists which are all pretty much unbelievable we get dealt a final twist, a reveal which we never see coming and it is a twist too far which rather than highlighting that Callie has always been a psycho comes across as ridiculous.

But the ridiculousness of the twists and the gaping plot holes are not the only issues as "Deadly Sibling Rivalry" is very much a typical made for TV movie. That means that scenes featuring rock climbing incidents are not overly exciting, the camera work is standard and the acting frequently is less than average. Of course actors will struggle with poorly written characters and there are a few here but it does seem that when ever we have a character that is meant to be bitchy they come across like a pantomime villain. There is also the fact we have Charisma Carpenter in the dual role of Janna and Callie and thankfully the script keeps it to a minimum so that we don't have the characters in the same scene too often. In fact Carpenter is quite effective in both roles as is Christa B. Allen who plays Janna's daughter Fiona even if her character does a lot of stupid stuff.

What this all boils down to is that "Deadly Sibling Rivalry" is a typical made for TV movie thriller and is full of the regular issues from plot holes to poor characters and some dodgy acting. But despite this there is something surprisingly watchable about it even if with the exception of some ridiculous plot twists it is relatively predictable.

Movie Recommendations


Seduced (2016)

Ever since her husband passed away Caroline (Elisabeth Röhm) has had her mi ...

Fatal Acquittal

Fatal Acquittal (2014)

When her husband is killed the finger of suspicion points firmly at Cassidy ...

A Mother

A Mother's Suspicion (2016)

Freshman Emily Yates (Paloma Kwiatkowski) tends to keep to herself and suff ...


Betrayed (2014)

With her divorce still to be finalised six months pregnant Julie (Amanda Sc ...

Suicide Note

Suicide Note (2016)

After comforting her roommate Emma (Kristen Ray) following the latest argum ...

Assumed Killer

Assumed Killer (2013)

On the way back from her mother-in-law's funeral, reporter Daria Valdez Mor ...

Killer Collector

Killer Collector (2016)

Following a robbery which went bad and ended up with a murder, Dayton (Casp ...

Reluctant Witness

Reluctant Witness (2015)

10 years earlier Erin (Mia Kirshner) was called Melissa and she used to be ...

Second Sight

Second Sight (2016)

As a little girl Clara Randall (Tatyana Ali) use to have visions and premon ...

Buried Secrets

Buried Secrets (2015)

Having been kicked off the force months earlier when then detective Joan Mu ...

Broken Promise

Broken Promise (2016)

When she was a teenager Mina (Ashley Scott) and Reese (Louis Mandylor) were ...

Stolen from the Womb

Stolen from the Womb (2014)

Two years after she lost her baby in the final trimester following several ...

Sandra Brown

Sandra Brown's White Hot (2016)

Having left her hometown in Louisiana more than a decade ago Sayre Hoyle (S ...

Fatal Friends

Fatal Friends (2015)

Sophia Allen (Sarah Grey) has dedicated her life to playing piano and hopes ...

The Cheerleader Murders

The Cheerleader Murders (2016)

When 16 year old Ellie (Samantha Boscarino) was a little younger a group of ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS