The Feisty Western Gal

Macdonald Carey and Will Geer in Comanche Territory (1950)

When silver is discovered on the land belonging to the Comanche, the U.S. government broker a deal to mine the land. But the locals living near to the land are yet to be made aware of any such agreement and their greed is threatening to cause unrest in the area especially when the new treaty doesn't reach the Comanches. The legendary James Bowie (Macdonald Carey) arrives in the area and following meeting politician Dan'l Seeger (Will Geer) who had been ambushed quickly realises that controlling the situation is not going to be simple as Katie Howard (Maureen O'Hara), a local business woman, appears to be involved in the trouble.

I don't know anyone who writes movie reviews who doesn't have a favourite actor or actress and it is always hard to not to be more generous with their movies than others. For me I have a weakness for Maureen O'Hara movies and as "Comanche Territory" sees her playing a feisty western gal it would be easy to get a little carried away in praising this western from 1950. But the thing is that whilst "Comanche Territory" is entertaining, especially for O'Hara's performance, it is also pretty routine with a storyline which sees an official trying to uncover who is behind the breaking of a peace treaty with the nearby Comanche as well as some romance.

Maureen O'Hara in Comanche Territory (1950)

As such what you get in "Comanche Territory" is Jim Bowie entering town and sniffing around whilst finding himself dealing with various locals; be it the feisty Katie or old timer Dan'l Seeger. You have the semi mystery as to who is really behind the trouble as Dan'l smelt fancy perfume when he was ambushed just prior to delivering the amendment to the treaty with the Comanche. And I could go on because I don't think there is a single part to "Comanche Territory" which I haven't encountered in other westerns.

But "Comanche Territory" is colourful and it is Maureen O'Hara delivering a feisty character which provides plenty of entertainment giving us that humour of a tough western gal who is tomboy-ish but finds herself ditching the buck skin and dressing up like a lady due to a spark of something with Bowie. Also providing some fun is Will Geer who just had a way of saying things which made them amusing. Unfortunately Macdonald Carey ends up far too bland as Bowie and lacks that real element of action man to make him an entertaining lead.

What this all boils down to is that "Comanche Territory" is certainly an entertaining movie for fans of old westerns and also Maureen O'Hara. But it is also a routine which one which could have done with a stronger actor in the lead as sadly Macdonald Carey is a little too bland in this.

Movie Recommendations

Copper Canyon

Copper Canyon (1950)

A group of Southern veterans, who following the war are working as copper m ...

Salt Lake Raiders

Salt Lake Raiders (1950)

When Silver City was plagued with violence from Brit Condor and his gang ba ...

Vigilante Hideout

Vigilante Hideout (1950)

Range detective Rocky Lane arrives in town as he heard that Nugget Clark ha ...

The Nevadan

The Nevadan (1950)

After escaping on his way to jail, outlaw Tom Tanner (Forrest Tucker) comes ...

Sunset in the West

Sunset in the West (1950)

When a train doesn't stop to take on board the cattle he has lined up, form ...

Thunder in the Dust

Thunder in the Dust (1950)

Like many a cattle rancher Tom (Robert Sterling) has found himself plagues ...

Dakota Lil

Dakota Lil (1950)

The government are aware of a major counterfeiting operation going on and s ...

Dynamite Pass

Dynamite Pass (1950)

Friends Ross (Tim Holt) and Chito (Richard Martin) arrive in Mesa City look ...

Kansas Raiders

Kansas Raiders (1950)

Angered by the "Redlegs" killing his parents Jesse James (Audie Murphy - 40 ...

A Ticket to Tomahawk

A Ticket to Tomahawk (1950)

The trains are coming but not if Dawson (Mauritz Hugo) can help it as if th ...

Wagon Master

Wagon Master (1950)

Elder Wiggs (Ward Bond) is leading his Mormon wagon train across country an ...


Dallas (1950)

After his home is torched and family is murdered by the Marlowe brothers fo ...

The Gunfighter

The Gunfighter (1950)

Legendary gunfighter Jimmy Ringo (Gregory Peck - Spellbound) has tired of t ...

Rio Grande

Rio Grande (1950)

After days of riding the Mexican border Lt. Col. Kirby Yorke (John Wayne - ...

Lust for Gold

Lust for Gold (1949)

Barry Storm (William Prince) has always believed in the legend that his gra ...

Follow The Movie Scene

Follow The Movie Scene on Twitter Like The Movie Scene on facebook Join The Movie Scene on Gplus Subscribe to The Movie Scene's RSS